MLB All-Star Game 2025 Preview: Odds, Betting Picks, and MVP Predictions
The Midsummer Classic heads to Truist Park in Atlanta on Tuesday, July 15 at 8:00 PM ET (FOX), featuring baseball’s brightest stars from the National League and American League in a battle for bragging rights—and betting value.
The National League is slightly favored heading into the 2025 All-Star Game, and with MVP odds and total plays offering plenty of angles, here’s everything you need to know before placing your wagers.
📊 2025 MLB All-Star Game Odds
(via FanDuel as of July 14)
| Team | Moneyline | Total Runs | Total Odds |
|---|---|---|---|
| National League | -116 | Over 7 | (-120) |
| American League | -102 | Under 7 | (-102) |
The odds imply a 55.6% chance of a National League win, though historically, the AL has dominated this exhibition with 28 wins in the last 35 games. However, the NL has turned things around recently, winning two of the past three.
🔥 Best Bet: National League ML (-125)
Despite the AL’s historical dominance, this year’s NL squad boasts deeper pitching and more high-upside youth in the lineup. Likely starter Paul Skenes brings electricity to the mound, backed by a bullpen stacked with elite relievers.
The NL also features more lineup balance than in previous years. With the line moving toward the National League, the slight favorite still holds value in what should be a low-scoring contest.
💣 Total Pick: UNDER 7.5 Runs (-110)
The Under has cashed in 5 of the last 7 All-Star Games—and this trend feels poised to continue. Both sides feature arms with sub-2.50 ERAs, and the nature of the game (a parade of shutdown relievers, limited at-bats for stars) lends itself to low-scoring affairs.
Unless totals dip below 6.5 in future years, the Under remains an automatic lean for sharp bettors.
📈 2025 MLB All-Star Game Betting Trends
- ✅ AL has won 28 of last 35 games.
- ✅ UNDER has hit in 5 of last 7.
- ✅ MVP has come from winning team 11 straight times.
- ✅ 8 of last 11 MVPs were hitters.
- ❌ No shortstop has won MVP since 2006 (Michael Young).
- 🧤 Only two pitchers have won MVP since 2000.
⭐ 2025 MLB All-Star Game MVP Odds
| Player | Odds |
|---|---|
| Shohei Ohtani | +550 |
| Aaron Judge | +600 |
| Pete Crow-Armstrong | +900 |
| Ronald Acuña Jr. | +1000 |
| Cal Raleigh | +1100 |
| Bobby Witt Jr. | +1700 |
| James Wood | +2000 |
| Tarik Skubal | +2500 |
| Kyle Stowers | +10000 |
🏅 Top MVP Picks
💎 Best Value Pick: Pete Crow-Armstrong (+900)
The Cubs outfielder fits the MVP mold: young, fast, and capable of doing a little bit of everything. He could shine defensively, steal a base, or deliver a clutch hit late in the game. MVPs often come from bench players who get at-bats in key moments—and Crow-Armstrong checks every box.
🎯 Longshot Sleeper: Kyle Stowers (+10000)
The Marlins slugger has quietly entered the break on fire, including a 5-for-5, 3-HR game just days ago. Stowers isn’t a starter, but that might actually work in his favor. In recent years, bench players have seized the MVP spotlight—just ask 2023’s Jarren Duran (50-1) or 2022’s Elias Díaz (200-1).
With monster odds and late-inning upside, Stowers is a lottery ticket worth considering if you like narrative-driven chaos.
🧢 Wildcard Option: James Wood (+2000)
Wood has been making waves all year and enters the All-Star break with momentum. While his raw power might not translate perfectly in one or two at-bats, a well-timed moonshot could make all the difference.
If the NL wins—and Wood is still in by the 5th or 6th—he’s a serious contender.
📝 MVP Strategy Tip
Stars like Ohtani or Judge may only get one at-bat, which limits their ceiling. Consider focusing on reserves who’ll see the field later, especially if they have power or speed.
A good MVP pick needs opportunity—and a memorable moment. Look for:
- Late-game pinch hitters
- Players batting with runners on base
- Defensive standouts who can shine with one big play
✅ Final Picks Recap
- 🏆 Moneyline: National League (-125)
- 💥 Total: Under 7.5 (-110)
- 🌟 MVP Value Bet: Pete Crow-Armstrong (+900)
- 🎰 MVP Sleeper: Kyle Stowers (+10000)
📢 Reminder: The 2025 MLB All-Star Game begins Tuesday, July 15 at 8 p.m. ET on FOX, live from Truist Park in Atlanta.
Please bet responsibly. For help, contact the National Gambling Helpline at 1-800-522-4700.