When betting on the MLB playoffs, consider that it is a different animal from the regular season, with a shorter series format, high-stakes games, and unique trends. Successful strategies focus on analyzing pitching matchups, considering home-field advantage, and managing your bankroll wisely.
General MLB playoff betting strategies
- Avoid big favorites. Betting on heavy favorites with very short odds (steeper than -160) is often a losing proposition in baseball, where upsets are common. In the playoffs, where every team is strong, underdogs often have an even better chance to win, providing more valuable payouts.
- Focus on First Five Innings (F5). F5 bets can remove the unpredictable nature of how bullpens perform under postseason pressure. By betting on the first five innings, you focus primarily on the starting pitchers and the top of the batting order, which is often more predictable.
- Consider totals (over/under) betting. Postseason games often feature the best starting pitching, which can lead to lower-scoring games and favorable odds for the Under. However, recent postseason totals have favored the Over, suggesting that odds are often shaded toward the Under. Always research the pitching matchup and weather conditions carefully.
- Home-field advantage. In some rounds, home teams have a significant edge. For example, in the divisional series, home teams holding a series lead or tied are on a historical hot streak, performing well on both the moneyline and run line.
- Fading public betting. Large betting volumes can sometimes influence odds away from where the true value lies. One strategy is to bet against the majority, especially in high-volume playoff games, as public perception can overvalue certain teams.
MLB Betting ideas for the Divisional Series (as of October 10, 2025)
ALDS: Mariners vs. Tigers (Game 5)
The series is tied 2-2, and the decisive Game 5 is scheduled for tonight.
- Mariners +1.5 on the run line (-170): With the series tied and a crucial game on the line, expecting a close game is reasonable. The Mariners have been resilient, and getting them +1.5 at good odds offers a safe way to play the outcome.
- Under 5.5 total runs (+100): This is a low total for an MLB game, but with the pressure of a Game 5, runs can be at a premium. Both teams will likely lean on their best available pitchers. Historically, Game 7 totals have trended toward the Under.
- Player prop: Tarik Skubal (Tigers) under 8.5 strikeouts (+126): Skubal is a talented pitcher, but relying on an exceptional strikeout performance in a high-pressure, elimination game is risky. He’s averaging 7.8 strikeouts per game, making the Under a potentially good value bet.
NLDS: Brewers vs. Cubs (Game 5)
The series is tied 2-2, and Game 5 is scheduled for tomorrow.
- Cubs moneyline (-102): In a “winner-take-all” game, the Brewers are currently favored, but only slightly. The Cubs have played well enough to force a Game 5 after losing the first two. With nearly even odds, taking the slightly undervalued moneyline offers a good return if the underdog Cubs can close out the series.
- Totals trends: Note that the Brewers and Cubs have trended dramatically toward the Under in past playoff action. While game-specific pitching matchups are vital, past series behavior can inform your decision on the total.
Player Prop Betting Tips
Player props offer unique opportunities beyond the game’s outcome.
- Research individual matchups: Look into how a specific batter performs against the opposing pitcher. For example, analyze a hitter’s home run potential against a pitcher they’ve previously seen success against.
- Focus on consistency: During the playoffs, the pressure is immense. Look for players who have demonstrated consistent performance rather than relying on one-off breakout candidates for high-volume props, like hits or strikeouts.
- Analyze game context: A powerful slugger might have better home run odds when facing a bullpen known for giving up long balls. A strikeout-prone hitter might be a good “Over” candidate for an opposing pitcher’s strikeout total.
Responsible gambling
Regardless of the betting strategy, responsible gambling is paramount. Set a strict budget, avoid chasing losses, and view betting as a form of entertainment rather than a way to earn money. If you or somone you know has a gambling problem, please call 1-800-GAMBLING
(The content on this page is for informational purposes only. BetHouse.com makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of information given or the outcome of any game or event.)
Recent
